Free Speech, Ravens, and Chicken

Last week Maryland politician Emmett C. Burns Jr. wrote this bizarre letter to Steve Bisciotti, the owner of the Baltimore Ravens. He was upset that a Ravens player, Brendon Ayanbadejo, was speaking out in favor of gay marriage. The letter is a diatribe against free speech as much as anything. Take for instance this gem:

“Many of my constituents and your football supporters are appalled and aghast that a member of the Ravens Football Team would step into this controversial divide and try to sway public opinion one way or another.”

He also throws in that Ayanbadejo should “concentrate on football and steer clear of dividing the fan base.” After comments so obviously anti-free speech the media has blasted Burns. I can’t blame them.

But I must ask the question, aside from the side of the issue being supported, how are Ayanbadejo’s comments any different than Dan Cathy’s [Chick-fil-a President]? In both cases a person in a public position, outside of politics, made a statement about their stance on an issue being debated in our country at this time. Both the media and the public have reacted to these two men and their comments very differently, and I’ll get to those reactions in a minute. My desire in this post is not to take some stance on this issue. I have one, but it is in process, and the thrust of this post is not to debate the issue of gay marriage–rather to make some observations about the way free speech is being handled in our country in relation to the issue. So my first observation from this most recent story is that Ayanbadejo and Cathy both made comments about gay marriage as public figures outside of politics.

From there we can dive into the reactions of the media and the public–let’s take the media first. Cathy was lambasted by countless media outlets for his comments. Ayanbadejo’s comments would never have made news if it wasn’t for Burns Jr.’s crazy letter (which I suppose is free speech too). It seems that free speech is accepted without much fanfare for those in favor of gay marriage but vilified for anyone opposed to it. The media has picked a side on this issue and so the majority of coverage is aimed at promoting a stance, not reporting. I reiterate, my point here is not about whether that is good or bad, only that it is. You may think the media is right because their stance on gay marriage is right, or you may not, but either way I am only pointing out that free speech is lauded on one side of this issue and demonized on the other.

Now for the public. I think the public largely follows the media (not necessarily in terms of their stance on an issue but in terms of how big an issue is perceived to be). For instance, the media made a huge deal of Dan Cathy’s comments and Chick-fil-a became the location of a cultural battle. People on both sides of the issue used their patronage or boycotting of a restaurant to make a statement. The long lines at Chick-fil-a, endless Twitter posts with #chicken, and subsequent protests resulted from the public taking their cue from the media that what Dan Cathy said was a big deal. Because the media is reporting some about Burns Jr. and Ayanbadejo, but very little in comparison, I doubt anyone will be selling their Ravens jersey or boycotting the games (or making a point to go to them for that matter). We as the public allow the media to decide what is a big deal and what isn’t. In retrospect I think it’s funny [and sad?] that we all allowed the media to get us riled up over what a restaurant owner thinks about gay marriage. I’m just not sure why we should care that much. I digress.

This issue is an interesting case study in free speech, the power of the media, and public action. Just some observations.

Advertisements

About Trevor Lee

Proud to be the husband of a wonderful wife and the father of two great kids. I love to hang out with them, hang out with others, read, lis

Posted on September 7, 2012, in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink. 1 Comment.

  1. In case you haven’t noticed, “free speech” really isn’t a freedom in this country anymore. It is a “free” element only if one aligns with the popular (secular) element. A secular figure may speak freely because he/she speaks with a “Christian” bias. A Christian speaks with a narrow, mean, out-of-date point of view. In an “open” society, such as contemporary America, only those views that express individualism have validity. In a society where everyone “does their own thing,” and is responsible only for themselves and to themselves, the ideas of higher standards of morality and obedience to an antiquated religious system or to a “God” that doesn’t exist, anyway, are archaic.

    Humans love the sound of their own voices. We all have a tendancy to be “clainging gongs” (or we would not have blogs, logs, Facebook, Twitter, or other forms of “social media.” We love to talk (not so much to listen); what we say isn’t as important as the saying of it. Few people really think of the impact or influence of their words (James talks about the power that is in the tongue; Proverbs often speaks of the wisdom of less speech and more listening). Joyce Meyer offers some rather practical advice on excess verbosity :’ Shut Up.’

    The celebrities of the world have us in their thrall — their words are golden (even if they are often foul and stupid and, sometimes, cruel). Politicians are known for their useless tongues. Caucasians are known for their “forked tongues.” Have you noticed that where the tongue is concerned very little that is good is ever said about it? There was a song in the 60s by Paul Revere and the Raiders called “Too Much Talk and Not Enough Action.” And, of couse, St. Francis says quite well: “Preach a sermon always; use words only when necessary.”

    Silence is Golden because gold is a rare and, therefore, precious thing. So, with that little bit of well known wisdom, I will take my own advice and be quiet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s